Skip to main content

Book Review: Conditional Citizens


Author Laila Lalami



Citizenship is conditional for people who live outside the privileged race, religion, gender, and class. As a naturalized citizen, Lalami offers her exploration and learning about the power dynamics in a country that tells conflicting stories about its values and convictions. In “Conditional Citizens,” Laila Lalami describes her experiences and reflections as a naturalized American citizen from Morocco. She deftly and thoroughly ponders the confluences of gender, religion, and race biases in the experiences of newcomers to the United States. Lalami balances personal observations with historical truths on deeply embedded inequalities in American society.

A renowned novelist, Lalami possesses an exceptional gift for storytelling that shines through in this collection of essays. Beyond casual prejudice lobbed by border patrol agents, safety is undermined by systemic oppression through legislation that targets women, people of color, Arabs, and Muslims. Her powerful testimony, deeply personal and sympathetic, takes the reader across the cultures of Morocco and the United States, drawing similarities and contrasts.

In the opening chapter, “Allegiance,” Lalami vividly and compellingly contrasts the feelings of hope and belonging during her naturalization ceremony with the stark reality of blatant discrimination. Through the chapter titled “Borders,” Lalami discusses how border policies and walls weaponize ideas of othering and dehumanization. Belonging is elusive even among those who strive hard to assimilate and integrate into their adopted home. In “Inheritance,” Lalami ponders the intersection of gender and safety in the appointment of Supreme Court Justice Brent Kavanaugh. Christine Blasey Ford bravely spoke out about the trauma she experienced. Ford’s experience shows that even as they enjoy racial privilege, white women in America are conditional citizens whose stories are not to be believed or taken seriously.

Lalami’s writings reflect a critical time period with deleterious effects on the lives of everyday Americans, mirroring xenophobic fervor. Yet, she also reminds us that citizenship has always been conditional for most because white supremacist sentiments and policies have always alienated groups of people in America. The essays are not just poignant, but also timely and relevant as anti-immigrant hysteria continues to pervade national discourse.

More About Laila Lalami

Popular posts from this blog

Medicine Wheel for the Planet

Jennifer Grenz, PhD       Working toward ecological healing requires awareness of how Indigenous ancestral knowledge and living ways can complement Western scientific approaches to environmental restoration and protection practices. Dr. Jennifer Grenz (Nlaxa’pamux mixed ancestry) worked for more than two decades as a field researcher and practitioner for environmental nonprofit organizations, where she worked with different levels of government, including First Nations in Canada. "Medicine Wheel for the Planet" compiles Grenz’s most potent realizations about the lack of forward movement in addressing an impending ecological catastrophe.  A warming climate impacts not only human lives but also the natural balance that relies on reciprocal relationships rooted in deep connections to the land. She uses the metaphor of the four directions of the Indigenous “medicine wheel” to invite openness to Indigenous teachings, letting go of colonial narratives, merging lessons f...

Memento - Embracing the Darkness

Dennis "Dizzy" Doan Stories about overcoming and persevering through family dysfunction, poverty, and mental health challenges offer hope and the promise of better days. Dennis “Dizzy” Doan’s memoir Memento: Embracing the Darkness is one such story, with the added complexity of being raised in an immigrant Vietnamese family. Doan’s parents dealt with the mental and emotional aftermath of war, which forcibly uprooted them from their homeland. In the United States, they struggled to create a safe and stable life for their two sons. Doan shares his journey of finding himself, his craft, and eventually a successful tattoo business in Southern California despite personal strife and run-ins with the law. Doan is best known for developing the aesthetic language to combat anti-Asian hate that erupted during the COVID-19 pandemic. His art series titled “Model Minority” went viral, sparking conversation about Asian American identities and harmful stereotypes. In Memento, Doan showcase...

Enlighten Me

Editor's Note: This review was originally published in Los Angeles Book Review . Author Minh Lê Standing up for oneself seems like doing the right thing. Binh did just that in the face of a racist school bully who was poking fun at his Asian heritage. But physically assaulting another student goes against school policy, and it was Binh who got in trouble. Binh shares a silent retreat with his family and younger siblings. Along with other children, he learns about stories from the previous lives of the Buddha. The stories are interesting, but for Binh, it is difficult to sit still and clear his mind when he misses his Gameboy. While he struggles with silence, he learns important lessons about friendship, community, and being present. In the graphic novel "Enlighten Me," award-winning author Minh Lê and bestselling illustrator Chan Chau tell the story of a boy who gains a better understanding of himself as he works on quieting the mind and reflecting on dharma. Lê and Ch...